Mozart's Letters:
A Legacy of Disappearances, Edits, and Forgeries
Unveiling the Irregularities and Manipulations in Mozart’s Correspondence.
The recently translated letters of Mozart reveal a puzzling pattern of missing originals, dubious authorship, and outright forgeries, casting doubt on the integrity of key documents. This tangled web—particularly within Mozart’s final years—demands a critical look to understand not only the man but also the influence of those who controlled his legacy.
Mozart: The Fall of the Gods
This book compiles the results of our studies on 18th-century music and Mozart, who has been revered for over two centuries as a deity. We dismantle the baseless cult of Mozart and strip away the clichés that falsely present him as a natural genius, revealing the contradictions in conventional biographies. In this work, divided into two parts, we identify and critically analyze several contradictory points in the vast Mozart bibliography. Each of the nearly 2,000 citations is meticulously sourced, allowing readers to verify the findings. This critical biography of Mozart emerges from these premises, addressing the numerous doubts raised by researchers.
"Mozart’s legacy, as seen through these letters, is less a window to the man himself and more a tapestry woven by those around him, where motives, omissions, and secrets were the fabric of his story."
Mozart: The Fall of the Gods
Mozart’s surviving letters, or what remains of them, are filled with glaring inconsistencies. Examining these letters reveals a peculiar narrative: missing originals, questionable entries, and edits that cast doubt on their authenticity and purpose. For example, in 1788, we find only five letters from Mozart, one of which survives only as a copy, while the others simply request funds. In 1791, this increases to 27 letters, yet 13 are not autograph, and 11 bear the “modifications” of his widow Constanze or her second husband, Nissen. The pattern in previous years shows a similarly scattered story.
Leopold’s Letters and a Sparse Record from Wolfgang
The body of correspondence between Mozart and his father, Leopold, could more accurately be called Leopold’s Letters. Up until 1777, roughly 350 letters are from Leopold, compared to only about 25 from Wolfgang. Between 1778 and 1779, Leopold’s 45 letters still exceed Wolfgang’s 30. Only from 1780 to 1783 does Wolfgang’s correspondence increase—about 130 letters, nearly all addressed to his father. After 1784, however, Wolfgang’s letters become sparse: 15 in 1784, then dropping to only two in 1785. While some letters may have been misplaced, others seem to be lost forever—censored, possibly, by later family members like his sister Nannerl and later his wife Constanze, to polish Wolfgang’s image and obscure certain relationships, notably with his former love, Aloysia Weber.
A Reluctant Writer and His Coded Messages
Mozart was hardly a keen letter-writer, tending toward a laziness that made even essential communication difficult. When he did write, he often veiled himself, rarely revealing his true thoughts. In requests for funds, particularly to his friend Johann Michael Puchberg, he seldom conveyed the full story. Sensitive matters, often coded or disguised in playful language, hint at hidden meanings. Some messages were even erased, partially torn, or entirely destroyed. Copying and “enhancing” letters, then discarding originals, was a common tactic used to shape Mozart’s image, whether for financial support, reputation management, or political gain.
The “Letter” to Lorenzo Da Ponte
One particularly disputed letter, supposedly sent to librettist Lorenzo Da Ponte in September 1791, exemplifies these doubts. The sole surviving copy, located in Berlin’s Prussian Library, lacks a signature or named addressee. Additionally, it describes Mozart in a state of extreme depression—at odds with his generally positive disposition despite health challenges. This discrepancy prompted editor Schiedermair to reject the letter as inauthentic.
Titles, Fables, and Imagined Performances
Even where letters are verified as authentic, caution is required. Mozart’s letters occasionally contain exaggerations and untruths: he claimed titles he did not hold, overstated his examination success in Bologna, fabricated concert appearances to justify loan requests, and even invented tales of rivalries. This surviving correspondence—missing, altered, and sometimes fabricated—reveals a portrait of Mozart shaped as much by omission as by his own hand.
You May Also Like
Mozart’s Illusory Triumphs
Leopold Mozart was a masterful storyteller, ever eager to glorify his children’s achievements, such as the supposed concert at the court of the Prince-Elector of Munich in 1762. Yet, no court records exist to substantiate these claims. In Vienna, despite Schlichtegroll’s embellished tales, Empress Maria Theresa simply referred to them as “beggars,” and the anecdote of young Mozart commanding Wagenseil to turn pages is nothing more than a fanciful fabrication.
The Myth of Mozart’s Sight-Reading Genius
Mozart’s so-called sight-reading miracles were less about supernatural talent and more about clever improvisation, as two key 18th-century witnesses make clear.
The Hidden Legacy of Michael Haydn
Mozart’s Symphony No. 37, K.444, is more Haydn than Mozart. How did this happen? A story of deception and misattribution unfolds.
The Myth of Mozart’s Education
For centuries, Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart has been celebrated as a musical prodigy, effortlessly composing masterpieces from a young age. However, when we peel back the layers of myth surrounding his early education, a different picture emerges—one in which his father, Leopold Mozart, plays a far more controlling and influential role than is often acknowledged. This article explores the true nature of Mozart’s education, examining how much of his early works can be attributed to his own genius, and how much was the product of his father’s meticulous and often self-serving guidance. Was Wolfgang’s brilliance entirely his own, or was it a crafted image designed by Leopold?
The Myth of Mozart’s Childhood
Mozart’s childhood is often romanticised, but behind the myth lies a more complex reality. This post explores the hidden dynamics within his family, questioning the traditional narrative of Mozart's early years and shedding light on the forgotten role of his sister,...
Bohemia or Moravia: Reconfiguring Music History
Why does music history insist on an Austrian narrative, when the contributions of other nations are just as crucial?