The Kolb Concerto
A Mozartian Mirage?
The Kolb Concerto is more than just another questionable addition to Mozart’s repertoire; it’s a prime example of how music history is often rewritten to suit commercial interests. With two conflicting versions, neither matching Mozart’s known style or instrumentation practices, the concerto has been a subject of scholarly debate for over a century. From Ernest Hess’s early criticism to the recent re-evaluation by Christoph-Hellmut Mahling, it’s clear that this piece does not fit within the Mozart canon. Instead, it appears to be a product of 19th-century French pedagogical traditions, misattributed to Mozart for the sake of bolstering his catalogue. Given the inconsistencies in style, structure, and instrumentation, it is time to reconsider what we accept as “authentically Mozart” and to question whether the so-called “Viennese Classical style” is more of a myth than a reality.
Mozart: The Fall of the Gods
This book compiles the results of our studies on 18th-century music and Mozart, who has been revered for over two centuries as a deity. We dismantle the baseless cult of Mozart and strip away the clichés that falsely present him as a natural genius, revealing the contradictions in conventional biographies. In this work, divided into two parts, we identify and critically analyze several contradictory points in the vast Mozart bibliography. Each of the nearly 2,000 citations is meticulously sourced, allowing readers to verify the findings. This critical biography of Mozart emerges from these premises, addressing the numerous doubts raised by researchers.
"If this is what passes for Mozart’s genius, then perhaps we’ve been deceived all along."
Mozart: The Fall of the Gods
When discussing the so-called Kolb Concerto in D major (K6 271a), one cannot help but notice the echoes of past debates surrounding other dubious works attributed to Mozart. Much like the infamous sixth concerto, this piece is a puzzle—poorly crafted counterpoint, weak harmonies, and an overall lacklustre musical quality suggest Mozart’s involvement was minimal, if at all. Some claim he only composed the more successful sections, but even these are far from convincing.
The authenticity of the Kolb Concerto has been questioned for over a century. Ernest Hess noted its numerous compositional errors, uncharacteristic phrasing, and unconvincing orchestration, all of which undermine the attribution to Mozart. Strangely, this seventh concerto exists in two versions: the full score from Aloys Fuchs’s collection at the Prussian Library in Berlin, and the separate parts copied by Eugène Sauzay in Paris in 1837. The sources do not align, and the original manuscript by Wolfgang is nowhere to be found, yet it was published under Mozart’s name in 1907. For decades, scholars clung to imaginative theories, desperately trying to place the concerto within Mozart’s timeline, until it was finally revealed as a forgery.
The likes of Georges De Saint-Foix and Yehudi Menuhin held onto the belief that the concerto had some connection to Mozart, while others, such as Alfred Einstein, suggested that it might merely be a sketch, with later composers filling in the gaps. Still, the inconsistencies pile up: the violin remains too high in pitch, excessive pizzicatos disrupt the slow movement, and strange tenth intervals appear in cadenzas supposedly added in the 19th century.
Even the title “Kolb” has no basis in reality. Several amateur violinists bore that name, but none can be conclusively linked to this work. In 1963, Carl Bär speculated that the concerto might be related to an entry in Joachim von Schiedenhofen’s diary from 1777. However, his assumptions rest on shaky ground, as details about Kolb are scant and confused.
By 1978, Christoph-Hellmut Mahling proposed that Mozart may have merely copied the concerto for personal use, lifting it from another contemporary composer. Subsequent studies dismissed Mozart’s authorship, linking the concerto instead to French styles, such as those of Kreutzer and Baillot, suggesting it was a teaching tool rather than an original work by Mozart. Mahling’s findings reinforced the notion that the concerto’s structure and features align more with early 19th-century French conservatory exercises than with Mozart’s authentic output.
In truth, the Kolb Concerto is likely a commercial product, packaged as Mozart’s to enhance its market appeal. Today, it is still performed under his name, despite mounting evidence against its authenticity. This should lead us to question the very concept of the so-called “Viennese Classical style.” Is it truly a coherent, historically grounded genre, or merely another construct shaped by politics and commerce?
You May Also Like
Mozart’s Illusory Triumphs
The story of the young Mozart’s so-called triumphs at the courts of Europe is a tale riddled with embellishments, half-truths, and fabrications—many courtesy of Leopold Mozart himself and those who later sought to mythologize his son. One such example is the visit to Munich on 12 January 1762.
The Vienna Disaster
The failure of La Finta Semplice in Vienna was a turning point for the Mozart family, revealing the cracks in the facade of Wolfgang’s prodigious reputation and prompting a desperate escape to Italy in search of redemption.
The Myth of Mozart’s Sight-Reading Genius
Mozart’s so-called sight-reading miracles were less about supernatural talent and more about clever improvisation, as two key 18th-century witnesses make clear.
The Hidden Legacy of Michael Haydn
Mozart’s Symphony No. 37, K.444, is more Haydn than Mozart. How did this happen? A story of deception and misattribution unfolds.
The Myth of Mozart’s Education
For centuries, Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart has been celebrated as a musical prodigy, effortlessly composing masterpieces from a young age. However, when we peel back the layers of myth surrounding his early education, a different picture emerges—one in which his father, Leopold Mozart, plays a far more controlling and influential role than is often acknowledged. This article explores the true nature of Mozart’s education, examining how much of his early works can be attributed to his own genius, and how much was the product of his father’s meticulous and often self-serving guidance. Was Wolfgang’s brilliance entirely his own, or was it a crafted image designed by Leopold?
The Myth of Mozart’s Childhood
Mozart’s childhood is often romanticised, but behind the myth lies a more complex reality. This post explores the hidden dynamics within his family, questioning the traditional narrative of Mozart's early years and shedding light on the forgotten role of his sister,...