Unraveling Myths and Reality

The Legend of Mozart's Miserere

The enduring popularity of the narrative surrounding Mozart’s Miserere highlights the allure of the prodigy myth, but as we peel back the layers, we uncover a more nuanced picture of his life and the musical landscape of the time. The reality often contrasts sharply with the romanticized tales that have shaped our understanding of his genius.

Mozart: The Fall of the Gods

This book offers a fresh and critical look at the life of Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, challenging the myths that have surrounded him for centuries. We strip away the romanticised image of the “natural genius” and delve into the contradictions within Mozart’s extensive biographies. Backed by nearly 2,000 meticulously sourced citations, this work invites readers to explore a deeper, more complex understanding of Mozart. Perfect for those who wish to question the traditional narrative, this biography is a must-read for serious music lovers and historians.

"The story of Wolfgang’s supposed transcription of the Miserere is a fabrication by Leopold, intended to enhance their status in Salzburg."

Mozart: The Fall of the Gods

The story of Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart’s encounter with Gregorio Allegri’s famous Miserere is one of the most cherished legends in musical history. It paints a picture of a young prodigy who, upon hearing the piece during Holy Week in Rome in 1770, memorized it and secretly transcribed it, defying the Church’s prohibition against copying sacred music. This tale has captivated generations, but how much of it is rooted in truth?

According to the narrative, Mozart and his father, Leopold, arrived in Rome during Holy Week, determined to experience the revered Miserere sung in the Sistine Chapel. The legend suggests that Mozart skillfully concealed his manuscript in a hat to make corrections after the performance. This act of musical daring supposedly garnered admiration from the assembled audience, including the famed castrato, Cristofori, who sang the piece.

However, this romanticized account raises several questions. The journey from Florence to Rome was arduous, taking five days, marked by inclement weather. Upon their arrival, Leopold wrote letters detailing their experience, yet he didn’t mention any noteworthy aspects of the Miserere performance on the day they attended the service. Instead, he described the difficulties of their travels and encounters with various dignitaries.

In our book, Mozart: The Fall of the Gods – Part I, we point out inconsistencies in this tale. Notably, the Mozart family arrived late and had not yet registered or presented their letters of recommendation, making it impossible for them to enter without proper accreditation. The Miserere of Allegri was performed on the Wednesday of Holy Week, but it was also customary to perform a different version by Tommaso Bai the following day. Leopold’s accounts do not clarify whether they heard Allegri’s work or Bai’s, leading to speculation that the details may have been conflated over time.

Additionally, the supposed prohibition against copying the Miserere is now widely regarded as a myth. Copies of Allegri’s work circulated freely in England and elsewhere, and even a musician in the Papal Chapel had obtained a copy for the English traveler Charles Burney during the same year. This suggests that the Miserere was not the closely guarded secret it was purported to be.

Despite the legend, it appears that Mozart may not have executed the extraordinary feat of transcribing the piece as widely believed. The practicalities of the situation—such as the lack of a keyboard in their cramped lodging—render it unlikely that Wolfgang could have composed a faithful version of the intricate Miserere from memory. In fact, as he would later demonstrate in his life, Mozart was unable to compose without access to a clavier.

The enduring popularity of this narrative highlights the allure of the prodigy myth surrounding Mozart. However, it also serves as a reminder of the complexities of historical interpretation. The reality of Mozart’s experiences is often overshadowed by the enchanting tales that surround them, complicating our understanding of his musical development.

As we peel back the layers of this legend, we uncover a more nuanced picture of Mozart’s life and the musical landscape of the time. The Miserere incident reflects not only the boy’s burgeoning talents but also the cultural and historical contexts in which he operated—contexts that were rife with exaggeration and myth-making.

In the end, while the story of Mozart and the Miserere may be steeped in legend, it is essential to approach such tales with a critical eye, recognizing the difference between the romanticized narratives of musical genius and the more complex realities of artistic development.

For a deeper understanding of the details and inconsistencies surrounding this legend, we invite you to read our book, Mozart: The Fall of the Gods – Part I, which elaborates on all the particulars and demonstrates that Mozart NEVER transcribed the Miserere. This is a tale concocted by Leopold.

You May Also Like

When the Myth Collapsed

When the Myth Collapsed

Vienna exposed the myth: La Finta semplice was riddled with errors, and Wolfgang’s supposed opera genius was nothing more than Leopold’s fabrication. With their reputation in ruins, father and son turned to Italy, hoping to rewrite history.

The London Notebook and the Vienna Disaster

The London Notebook and the Vienna Disaster

Far from the myth of a flawless young genius, Mozart’s London Notebook reveals musical struggles and guided exercises, while the Vienna opera disaster proved that his father played a far greater role in his compositions than legend would have us believe.

Versailles, Vanity, and the Pursuit of Prestige

Versailles, Vanity, and the Pursuit of Prestige

Leopold Mozart’s letters transformed his son’s European tour into a carefully staged fantasy—filled with exaggerated encounters, fabricated royal admiration, and a relentless pursuit of social prestige. But how much of it was real?

The Fabricated Childhood of Mozart

The Fabricated Childhood of Mozart

The legend of young Mozart’s divine genius crumbles under scrutiny, revealing a childhood dictated by Leopold’s ambition, carefully constructed myths, and a relentless pursuit of fame at the expense of genuine artistic education.

The Man Behind the Myth

The Man Behind the Myth

Leopold Mozart’s legacy has been shaped by myths and hagiographies, but his letters reveal a man more concerned with financial gain and self-promotion than artistic integrity. Was he truly a devoted father, or simply an opportunist?

Constanze vs. The Catholic Church

Constanze vs. The Catholic Church

For over two centuries, scholars have debated the circumstances surrounding Mozart’s burial. Constanze Mozart’s supposed inability to mark his grave, the confrontation with the Catholic Church over funeral masses, and the baffling disappearance of Mozart’s body all contribute to a mystery stranger than fiction. Did a powerful group keep her silent? And what really happened to Mozart’s remains?