Leopold Mozart’s Fabricated Legacy
The False Sonnet of Corilla Olimpica
Leopold Mozart’s relentless pursuit of fame for his son Wolfgang led to questionable tactics, including fabricating a sonnet by the renowned poetess Corilla Olimpica. This desperate attempt to elevate Wolfgang’s reputation casts a shadow over the Mozart legacy.
Mozart: The Fall of the Gods
This book offers a fresh and critical look at the life of Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, challenging the myths that have surrounded him for centuries. We strip away the romanticised image of the “natural genius” and delve into the contradictions within Mozart’s extensive biographies. Backed by nearly 2,000 meticulously sourced citations, this work invites readers to explore a deeper, more complex understanding of Mozart. Perfect for those who wish to question the traditional narrative, this biography is a must-read for serious music lovers and historians.
"Leopold Mozart's false claim that Corilla Olimpica wrote a sonnet for Wolfgang was not just a father’s exaggeration—it was a deliberate fabrication to manufacture a legacy that never existed."
@MozartrazoM
One of the most infamous examples of Leopold Mozart’s manipulative behaviour during Wolfgang’s Italian tour in 1770 involves the celebrated poetess Maria Maddalena Morelli Fernandez, better known as Corilla Olimpica. According to Leopold’s letters, Corilla supposedly composed a sonnet in honour of Wolfgang, delivered by the English violinist Thomas Linley. However, this story is full of glaring inconsistencies, pointing to a deliberate fabrication by Leopold in his effort to promote his son.
Corilla was a respected figure in the Florentine cultural scene, renowned for her eloquent poetry. Yet, the so-called sonnet Da poi che il Fato t’ha da me diviso, supposedly dedicated to Wolfgang, is riddled with grammatical errors and lacks any reference to Mozart’s actual musical talents. Its generic content could have been directed at anyone, making it highly unlikely that Corilla, known for her precision, would have penned such a lacklustre piece.
More damning is the fact that Corilla herself never mentioned writing any poem for Mozart, nor did Linley, the alleged intermediary. The complete absence of this event from contemporary records and Corilla’s own writings strongly suggests that Leopold invented the entire episode. It seems that Leopold, ever the ambitious stage father, was willing to bend the truth to construct a narrative that would further glorify his son. By associating Wolfgang with prominent cultural figures like Corilla, Leopold hoped to boost his son’s status in the eyes of the aristocracy and potential patrons.
Leopold’s need to fabricate this sonnet speaks volumes about the lengths he was willing to go. Far from being an innocent promoter of his son’s talent, he consistently manipulated events and exaggerated Wolfgang’s achievements. The supposed involvement of Corilla Olimpica in Mozart’s early career is yet another instance of Leopold’s unscrupulous methods to establish his son’s reputation, even at the cost of truth.
The reality is that Corilla, at the time, was far more focused on her relationship with the violinist Pietro Nardini, not on some adolescent prodigy passing through Florence. Leopold’s fabrication reveals a deep insecurity about his son’s place in the musical world, and this episode casts serious doubt on the authenticity of many accounts from Wolfgang’s early career.
You May Also Like
The Misattribution of Mozart’s K.2 89a (K.6 73i): A Questionable Canon
K.2 89a (K.6 73i), attributed to Mozart, is riddled with issues—missing voices, incomplete harmonies, and even the absence of text. Should this piece really be in his catalogue?
The Borrowed Simplicity: Mozart’s Canons K.555, K.557, and K.562
The canons K.555, K.557, and K.562, often overlooked for their simplicity, reveal striking similarities with the works of Antonio Caldara. These three pieces, dated 1788, demonstrate how Mozart adapted and simplified Caldara’s contrapuntal structures, masking his influences while reflecting the galant style of the era.
Simplicity, Errors, and the Myth of Perfection
Mozart’s canons are not as complex as often claimed, with notable errors in K.553 and K.554, and the myth of “V’amo di cuore teneramente” K.348 being debunked.
The Uncertain Origins of Mozart’s Early String Quartets
Mozart’s so-called “Milanese Quartets” (K.155, 158, and 159) have long been subject to debate, primarily due to their ambiguous instrumentation and structural weaknesses. Were these works part of a larger series of orchestral divertimenti, hastily repurposed as string quartets? The answer remains elusive, reflecting the young composer’s struggles to find his own voice.
Mozart’s Quartet of Lodi: A Dated Work with Many Influences
Mozart’s Quartet of Lodi is often praised as an early masterpiece. But was it really his own work?
The Hidden Influence of Joseph Boulogne, Chevalier de Saint-George
Joseph Boulogne, known as the “Black Mozart”, was shaping the future of music while Mozart was still struggling for recognition in Paris. But history has buried the significant influence Saint-George had on Mozart’s career, erasing his pioneering style from the narrative.