Wolfgang Amadé Mozart
The Mozart Myth Unveiled: A Deeper Look at the Deception Surrounding His Legacy
Mozart’s legacy is far from the untarnished narrative of genius that history would have us believe. The web of deceit woven around his name by those closest to him, including his own widow, reveals a much darker story.
Mozart The Construction of a Genius: The Untold Story
Mozart: The Construction of a Genius” uncovers how the myth of Mozart was crafted after his death in 1791, initially to support his widow, then exploited by publishers, and later used to elevate Mozart as a cultural icon. Bianchini and Trombetta reveal that the personal catalogue attributed to Mozart is a late 18th-century fabrication, challenging long-held beliefs about his legacy.
“Constanze Mozart was fully aware that the hymn attributed to her late husband was, in fact, the work of August Eberhard Müller. Yet, she perpetuated the lie, presenting it as a genuine Mozart composition—a deception that continues to mislead even today”
Mozart The Construction of a Genius
Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart is often heralded as a musical genius, but beneath the surface of this glorified narrative lies a web of deceit and fabrication that has distorted his true legacy. Far from the infallible icon of classical music, Mozart’s name has been misused and manipulated, particularly by those closest to him, to propagate falsehoods for personal gain.
The Forged Bass Continuo School
In 1796, an advertisement in the Wiener Zeitung promoted a so-called ‘undiscovered manuscript’ by Mozart, known as the Bass Continuo School. This work, supposedly authored by the composer, was vouched for by none other than Constanze’s later husband, Von Nissen. Despite his assurances, the manuscript was nothing more than an elaborate forgery. Astonishingly, it took until the 19th century for this fact to be fully recognised, yet even today, the work is still mistakenly believed to be authentic in some circles. This incident marks just one of the many times Mozart’s name was exploited to sell fraudulent compositions.
Constanze Mozart’s Role in Perpetuating the Fraud
Constanze Mozart, Wolfgang’s widow, played a pivotal role in perpetuating these fabrications. Desperate for financial security, she repeatedly sold what she claimed to be ‘autograph’ versions of Mozart’s works, including his famous Requiem. Despite being incomplete drafts, she presented them as finished masterpieces, leading to her being publicly reprimanded for her dishonesty. Constanze’s actions reveal a troubling willingness to deceive, driven by her need to capitalise on Mozart’s fame.
The Role of August Eberhard Müller
Another key figure in this web of deceit was August Eberhard Müller, a musician who benefited from having his own compositions falsely attributed to Mozart. Among these spurious works were various pieces listed in the Köchel Catalogue’s appendix, including a hymn that Müller performed in Leipzig under the guise of a Mozart composition. Müller’s readiness to accept, if not encourage, this misattribution highlights the extent to which Mozart’s name was exploited by those eager to bask in his reflected glory.
The Enduring Legacy of Deception
Even years after Mozart’s death, these forgeries continued to circulate, with works like the Bass Continuo School and Müller’s hymn still mistakenly believed to be genuine Mozart compositions. The persistence of these fabrications underscores how deeply ingrained the myth of Mozart has become in the classical music world. The readiness of individuals like Constanze and Müller to distort the truth for personal benefit casts a long shadow over Mozart’s legacy, prompting us to question how much of what we believe about him is truly authentic.
You May Also Like
Mozart and Salieri
Pushkin does not see Salieri as a mere mediocre. In fact, Salieri embodies the struggle of the artist, much like Michelangelo, who reaches greatness through relentless effort. Pushkin himself identifies with both Mozart and Salieri, but he emphasises that true art demands work, discipline, and sacrifice. In poisoning the Mozartian element within himself, Salieri performs a service to art, freeing it from the frivolity of effortless genius. ‘Can genius and malice coexist?’ Pushkin’s answer is complex, but in the end, Salieri’s act seems to affirm that true creation lies in the hands of those who strive.
Another Example of Borrowed Genius
The myth of Mozart’s genius continues to collapse under the weight of his reliance on others’ ideas, with Leopold orchestrating his son’s supposed early brilliance.
A Genius or a Patchwork?
The genius of Mozart had yet to bloom, despite the anecdotes passed down to us. These concertos were not the work of a prodigy, but a collaborative effort between father and son, built on the music of others.
Myth, Reality, and the Hand of Martini
Mozart handed over Martini’s Antiphon, not his own, avoiding what could have been an embarrassing failure. The young prodigy had a lot to learn, and much of what followed was myth-making at its finest.
Mozart’s Serenade? A New Discovery? Really?
In Leipzig, what was thought to be a new autograph of Mozart turned out to be a questionable copy. Why are such rushed attributions so common for Mozart, and why is it so hard to correct them when proven false?
Mozart’s Thematic Catalogue Exposed as a Forgery
A groundbreaking forensic analysis reveals that Mozart’s thematic catalogue, long thought to be his own work, is a posthumous forgery. This discovery, detailed in Mozart: The Construction of a Genius, turns centuries of Mozart scholarship on its head, demanding a re-examination of his legacy.